Predator versus Enabler

In a week when two notorious sexual predators from the entertainment industry made national headlines in Britain, the BBC’s classical music station, Radio 3, decided to broadcast a live recording of Mozart’s opera celebrating the ultimate sexual predator, Don Giovanni.

One could argue that the timing of the broadcast was either insensitive or apposite, given that in the opera’s climactic scene the unrepentant Don is dragged down to hell.

For many opera goers, the most likable and sympathetic character in the drama is not any of the female victims of the Don, but rather his put-upon servant Leporello. It is Leporello who has the opera’s best-loved aria in which he details the Don’s “catalogue of conquests” in a futile attempt to console the spurned Donna Elvira.

And yet, in the modern context of sexual predators, Leporello would undoubtedly be labelled as an enabler. He continually complains and grumbles about his boss’ appalling behaviour but he never does anything to intervene; on the contrary, he is quite willing to play a key role in the Don’s nefarious schemes and deceptions. His only display of empathy towards the victims is to shrug and say “you are just one of many.”

Of course, Leporello is a feudal servant who has little power and, in theory, has to obey his master at all times. But audiences who watched Mozart’s The Marriage of Figaro, premiered the year before Don Giovanni, understood that resourceful servants can and do get the better of their horrible bosses if they put their mind to it. For all his complaints, Leporello has a sneaking admiration for his charismatic and charming boss and stays with him until the bitter end.

Today, you might think that personal assistants and others employed in the service of rich and powerful individuals would have more freedom to blow the whistle or simply walk away. But omnipresent non-disclosure agreements and threats that “you will never work in this industry again” put huge pressure on people to keep quiet. And as we have seen from the two celebrity cases currently in the news, these predators can use legal threats and injunctions to stop anyone exposing their wrongdoing.

I am sure there are some today who feel constrained by their position in the industry and, like Leporello, decide to put their own self-interest above those of their boss’ victims. But these functionaries are certainly not the primary enablers. The worst offenders are those who are not beholden to the predator but are in a position to profit off him. This catalogue includes the law firms hired by the predator to threaten victims and silence investigative journalists, the organisations that provide them with a public platform, and the companies that pay them vast sums of money for their services.

Lawsuits in England are hugely expensive and time-consuming, and law firms can profit immensely by defending their clients (win or lose) from accusations of wrongdoing. Likewise, publishing houses with a best-selling author are unlikely to distance themselves from that author immediately allegations of predatory behaviour surface or are even proven. In the case of the well-known individual at the centre of the current scandal, the publishing company initially only put guardrails in place, stating that young female employees should not visit the predator’s home by themselves. It was only after a new (female) chief executive officer took over that the company announced it would no longer publish his books, including the back-catalogue.

Television production companies have a long history of keeping predatory stars on air until allegations that had been an open secret for years become impossible to ignore. Young and vulnerable employees who are trying to get a foothold in television are invariably placed on tenuous short-term contracts; they don’t know who to talk to about bad behaviour or how to make a complaint, especially if the object of that complaint is the star of the show. As such, predatory behaviour can continue unchecked for years, even decades. And once the truth does emerge, the company can try to claim plausible deniably and retrofit the sequence of events so that its brand is not tarnished.

So, do these high-level enablers deserve the same or even a greater degree of moral censure than the actual predator? After all, the predator can only engage in such behaviour for as long as he is provided with the means and opportunity to do so. I think it is a moot point. Of greater importance is the wider social acceptability of male predatory behaviour. Tolerance of or even in some cases celebration of bad behaviour simply empowers the predator further and encourages those around him to profit off that bad behaviour.

Mozart described Don Giovanni as a dramma giocoso (a playful drama), suggesting that, at the time, the Don’s behaviour whilst reprehensible was also highly entertaining. It is clear from the two celebrity cases making headlines now that little has changed.